To Make a Living We Must Wreck Our Home?

Coal mine amidst farmland

Coal mine amidst farmland

[Published on Independent Australia 14 May]

I spend a lot of my days trawling the follies of our time. To avoid sinking into the mire of despair I need to keep a firm hold of love and hope and grandchildren. But every now and then something lands too heavily in my heart, and I can only grieve.

Tarwyn Park is the Hunter Valley property where Peter Andrews worked out how to get the water back into the ground, by reconstructing a degraded creek so it flows slowly and the water can soak across the valley. His work is revolutionising the way we live in the Australian landscape, restoring its original productivity and resilience in the face of our challenging climate. We learnt last Monday, May 4th, in the ABC’s Australian Story that Tarwyn Park has been, very reluctantly, sold so it can be dug up for the coal that underlies the valley. It would be hard to find a more apt metaphor for the blind stupidity of Australia’s ruling class.

Productive agricultural land is to be sacrificed. The beloved and iconic family property, the living scientific experiment, is so much overburden, to be scraped off to reach the dollars below. Across the country farmland, communities, nature reserves and ecosystems are under assault from miners, frackers, and developers. They rabbit on about the billions of dollars and thousands of jobs, but the dollars will buy stranded assets, most of the profit will flow overseas, and they wildly exaggerate the number of jobs, which won’t last that long anyway. They talk of “rehabilitating” land, but in rank ignorance of the complex hydrological, ecological and human systems they have disrupted. Once the groundwater is contaminated, it can’t be cleaned. You can’t just plant a few trees and shrubs and expect the land to heal. You can displace whole communities, but lives are changed forever. It would be crazy enough if it were just the greed, but the coal frenzy currently gripping Australia is a death warrant for our global industrial system. The world’s coal-burning infrastructure is close to the point where it will push global warming above 2°C if it is allowed to burn for its projected lifespan. 2°C of warming is supposed to be the limit under which our politicians are aiming to keep us. That number never had a clear scientific basis, and there is increasing evidence it is too high. Already, at 0.8°C, the huge Antarctic ice sheet is showing disturbing signs of being destabilised, and many other symptoms of global warming are occurring sooner than expected. Anything above 1.5°C, or even 1°C, may pass tipping points into irreversible catastrophic warming. What they are telling us, over and over, the miners, the spruikers, the politicians, the media cheer squad, is that the only way we can make a living in Australia is by wrecking our home. They are blind to the future they are committing us to. They are deaf to the sane alternative. There are more jobs to be gained from investing the billions in clean energy and restorative agriculture, jobs that will last indefinitely and give our grandchildren healthy and secure lives. Germany, that epitome of the modern industrial state, is moving rapidly along the clean energy path in a climate much less suitable than ours. There are plenty of clean jobs and industries that can give us a good living while we preserve and restore this remarkable land. Connecting a few more dots, if we wean ourselves off oil we can stop meddling in the Middle East, cease being a target of terrorism and reduce the displacement of people who become refugees. Then Four Corners, the program following Australian Story last Monday, was about exploitation of agricultural workers, another depressing portrayal of how low we’re sinking. Connecting more dots, the problem is Coles’ and Woolworths’ relentless cost cutting, requiring ever-lower prices paid to suppliers. They are driving our farmers out of business and promoting unsustainable factory farming run on exploited labour. When even that isn’t cheap enough, they import diseased berries from China. The competitive push for ever-lower prices throughout the economy is unsustainable, because suppliers and workers are customers too. It impoverishes customers at the expense of shareholders. It is market fundamentalism run amok. If you want to know where that leads, look at the United States, which is in rapid decline. The ABC, battered, intimidated, underfunded and occupied, no longer seems to see the big picture. It spent much of Australian Story on the Andrews family tensions, tabloid-style. Four Corners named Coles and Woolies as bad guys, but didn’t expose the pressure they are under, from nonsense neoliberal policies. Australians have never supported market fundamentalism. They are slowly beginning to push back. That is why there’s a feral Senate. It’s called democracy. I cling to my hope we will take back our thoroughly corrupted Parliament, and choose a sane and healthy future.

3 thoughts on “To Make a Living We Must Wreck Our Home?

  1. Farm-Art-Think

    Hi Geoff,

    Hope all is well with you and Julia and that 2 fires is all coming together from your perspective. Looking forward to it.

    This is a great post. Very near to the interests of our members and readers of the Flood Creek Non-nativist Landcare blog. Would you mind if I “re-blogged” it?

    Reblogging isn’t something I’ve done before, so I thought I’d better ask permission. I assume the wordpress ‘re-blog’ function provides proper attribution and links to your original post.

    Let me know.

    All the very best, Ben


    1. Geoff Davies Post author

      Yes, go for it Ben. It’ll probably link back to here, but I’m just happy for the word to be spread around.


  2. nonnativistlandcare

    Reblogged this on Flood Creek Non-Nativist Landcare and commented:
    Geoff Davies is a Braidwood local with a passion for the environment and a firm commitment to interrogating and reforming our economic system. Geoff has published several books and writes on his blog ‘Better Nature’. Geoff’s work incorporates ecological, social and ethical realities, which dominant economic discourse ignores to our detriment.

    Here Geoff reflects on a recent ‘Australian Story’ program which dealt with the sale of Tarwyn Park to an international coal mining corporation. Tarwyn Park will be familiar to some readers of the Flood Creek Non-Nativist Landcare Group blog as the home of the Andrews family, where Peter Andrews perfected his techniques for farming in accord with the ‘Natural Sequence’ of the Australian landscape.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s